
That's what "Mellon Financial Center" attorney John Lanzetta thinks:
In the '70s, Democratic President Jimmy Carter started it off with his efforts at financial deregulation and his Community Reinvestment Act, which encouraged and pressured banks to make loans to those who were theretofore unbankable.That sweater-wearing jerk! Then the big ole' mean government made financial institutions all over the world do crazy things:
Banks, worried about the risks that Democrats had made them take, began hiding risky loans with good loans in complicated security instruments such as credit-default swaps.So society is to blame, government is to blame, and we all turned the banks into victims.
Johnny, whatever happened to personal responsibility?
BTW, before you get all teary-eyed for what Carter did to those nice banks, consider that the opposite is factually correct:
This makes my head hurt -- I'd rather blame the sweater.''There is no evidence that the Community Reinvestment Act was responsible for encouraging the subprime lending boom and subsequent housing bust,'' wrote Luci Ellis, an economist for the Switzerland-based Bank for International Settlements, last month in her working paper ``The housing meltdown: Why did it happen in the United States?''
In her study, which examined the calamity enveloping global financial markets, Ellis wrote that deposit banks covered by CRA ``showed a lesser tendency to write subprime loans than lenders not subject to the act.''
Even if you include subprime loans made by CRA-covered banks and thrifts, the vast majority of the toxic loans stinking up mortgage-backed securities had nothing to do with CRA compliance.
More than half of subprime loans were made by independent mortgage companies not subject to comprehensive federal supervision; another 30 percent of the loans were made by affiliates of banks or thrifts subject to routine examination or supervision, according to congressional testimony given earlier this year by Michael S. Barr, a professor at the University of Michigan Law School.
''The worst and most widespread abuses occurred in the institutions with the least federal oversight,'' Barr testified.
Traiger & Hinckley, a New York law firm that represents lenders complying with CRA regulation, took a look at whether the law encouraged irresponsible lending.
''CRA banks were significantly less likely than other lenders to make a high-cost loan,'' the law firm's report found. When CRA banks did originate high-cost loans, the average APR was appreciably lower than the average APR on high-cost loans originated by other lenders.
Further, CRA banks were more than twice as likely as other lenders to retain originated loans in their portfolio, said Warren Traiger, a partner at Traiger & Hinckley.
''If more lenders were covered by CRA, the crisis would have been mitigated,'' Traiger said in an interview.
The investment banks who purchased, bundled and securitized subprime loans were not covered by CRA, points out Matthew Lee, executive director of Inner City Press, a nonprofit community advocacy group based in the New York borough of the Bronx.
22 comments:
The only sweater-wearing jerk here is John Lanzetta.
Take your salt SFL -
They call it stormy monday
But tuesdays just as bad.
They call it stormy monday
But tuesdays just as bad.
Lord, and wednesdays worse
And thursdays all so sad.
The eagle flies on friday,
Saturday I go out to play.
The eagle flies on friday,
Saturday I go out to play.
Sunday I go to church,
Gonna kneel down and pray.
Lord have mercy,
Lord have mercy on me.
Lord have mercy,
Lord have mercy on me.
Though Im tryin and tryin to find my baby,
Wont someone please send her home to me.
"I've looked on a lot of women with lust. I've committed adultery in my heart many times.."
Typical GOP bullshit. If something good happens in/to the country, it's to the GOP's credit. If something bad happens, blame Pelosi/Reid/Clinton/Gore/Carter/Mondale/Johnson/JFK/Truman/FDR/_________ (fill in blank with any prominent Democrat).
The GOP disgusts me right now.
7:01--agreed.
Nice ending SFL.
6:56, Great presidential quote.
Solid post SFL.
Where do you find the energy to post so early? That's right, you work behind the camera.
Great post. Boil it down and it's a new way to blame minorities.
Boy you folks are feisty today!
I thought the sweater belonged to Mr. Rogers?
7:26--Good point.
7:31-- Feisty? That's pretty funny coming from you SFL.
7:41, newbies' been smoking some cheap ass weed.
Maybe newbster is smoking weed found in his yard. Hey newbs you do know the difference?
Lanzetta, you are a tool:
http://tinyurl.com/4q7glr
9:08, good stuff.
SFL why so mum? Filled with too much turkey?
Alan, the sweater you posted must be from your era.
What about this: executives of discredited insurer AIG spent $440,000 on a corporate retreat in California one week after getting an $85 billion government bailout. Included in the bill is $147,000 for banquets and $23,000 for spa treatments.
6:47/9:08, agreed.
7:19, it may appear the director
does most of the work but we know who really works up a sweat.
SFL your head hurts from watching too many 'home' movies.
10:36, criminal charges need to be brought up.
12:02, If SFL head hurts from excessive movie viewing imagine the kind of pain the princess is in from preforming.
Where is SFL?
12:57, maybe he ran out of syrup and made a trip up North.
1:53, and video tapes. I hear they're cheaper up there, eh?
The free market failed, but the free market fanatics will never admit it so the blame the CRA. Even though most of the toxic loans were made by independent mortgage lenders not subject to the CRA. And the CRA specifically mandates safe lending practices. Republicans don't want to blame the poor white base, so have to bring up the scaaaary inner city black population as the Real Cause of the Problem (tm).
Someone will have to explain what video tapes are to the newbie.
Post a Comment