Thursday, March 17, 2011

Judge King Defaults Wachovia for Blowing Deadline -- Time to Take REALLY Deep Breath.



Mere hours after Judge Gold's excellent FBA speech on mindfulness, Judge King reminded counsel -- including heavyweights at Hunton & Williams and Birmingham's Maynard Cooper & Gale, that it's probably a good idea to double or triple calendar dates to respond to an amended complaint -- even if someone else is supposed to be handling it.

Why, you might ask?

All the Judge did was sua sponte enter a default against Wachovia for failing to respond to the Amended Complaint in an auction rate securities action!

The next day, after much deep breathing exercises I am sure (ed. note -- and possibly a call to the carrier), Birmingham lawyer Carl S. Burkhalter took one for the team (he also referenced his secretary and departed associate):
Defendant has not filed a timely answer to Plaintiff’s amended complaint. The reason for that failure, as explained below and in an accompanying declaration, is that the deadline date for answering Plaintiff’s amended complaint was not entered on the calendar of Carl S. Burkhalter, the undersigned attorney and primary defense counsel in this matter. The undersigned attorney depends on an associate and his secretary to docket deadline dates, but the associate in question (Ms. Prim Formby Escalona) left the firm in January 2011, whereas the undersigned’s secretary was unaware of the deadline and, thus, failed to make a calendar entry. Having said that, it is the undersigned’s duty to meet court-imposed deadlines. He accepts complete responsibility for this failure and he is profoundly sorry for the oversight.
Note to Carl -- your secretary does not get CM/ECF emails, you do.  Did you forward it to her?

Here's what he says happened:
Ordinarily, the February 17th deadline would have been docketed on the undersigned’s calendar by either or both of two persons: the associate on the file or Ms. Laura Juarez, the undersigned’s secretary. See Burkhalter Declaration. Unfortunately, these redundant systems failed in this instance, something that has never before happened in the undersigned’s twenty-year practice of law. The associate, Ms. Prim Formby Escalona, had left the firm in early January 2011 to become Chief Deputy for the Alabama Solicitor General. Id. In the undersigned’s federal court cases, any e-mail notices he receives are usually “auto-forwarded” to Ms. Juarez, who then makes the relevant deadline notation on the undersigned’s calendar. However, for some unknown reason, the “auto-forwarding” rule did not function in this instance, meaning that Ms. Juarez did not make a deadline entry on the undersigned’s calendar.
Oh boy.

Life happens, as they say.

Let's see what the plaintiff has to say about all this:
While Mr. Burkhalter’s efforts to take responsibility for Wachovia’s failure to timely comply with the Court’s Order appear sincere, they ignore the fact that two other current Wachovia lawyers were served with the Order and Amended Complaint. Thus, the Motion sets forth no good cause for their – or Wachovia’s – failure to timely respond. Moreover, the Motion fails to provide evidence in support of its purported defenses to STLA’s claims. Meanwhile, STLA is prejudiced by the delay. For these reasons, the Motion should be denied.
The Court has not yet ruled on the motion.

Who says being a litigator ain't stressful?

23 comments:

Anonymous said...

"Usually" auto-forwarded does not make sense

Anonymous said...

he is not taking "full responsibility." he is blaming it on the associate and on the secretary.

Anonymous said...

What does "sue sponte" mean?

Anonymous said...

Oh, you're SOOOOOOO BUUUSSSSYYYYYY.

This "redundant system" (which is not) failed because he abdicates calendaring and receipt of CM/ECFs to other people. Recipe for disaster, which is what happened. Why would you not want to directly receive a communication from the court?

A true redundant system would be for the attorney to hand-write deadlines on a desk calendar and for his assistant to contemporaneously place the deadline in the Outlook calendar.

WOMP WOMP

Anonymous said...

Ditto 1:52.

Anonymous said...

But, for the grace of God, go I.

Anonymous said...

I am profoundly sorry for not personally reviewing emails sent to me by the court. I am profoundly sorry my associate left and we didn't let the court know and I still assumed she was calendaring dates for me on this case. I am profoundly sorry my co-counsel act as mere mail drops. I am profoundly sorry an email sent to me was not auto-forwarded to my secretary. I am profoundly sorry.

Anonymous said...

Do you think the malpractice carriers have been notified? Or, do they wait until the motion is ruled upon? Which of the firms involved is most likely to bill for this motion?

FREE CARL S. BURKHALTER said...

Shirts will soon be available at my etsy shop.

Anonymous said...

lol.... judge king should let him off the hook. otherwise the 11th will

Anonymous said...

Above the Law linked to you again!

Group 37 - Perez, Gladys 2012 said...

If you file to run against County Court Judge Gladys Perez in the 2012 Election this writer will guarantee you volunteers and cash donations like never before seen in any judicial race in history.

Group 37 - Perez, Gladys 2012

Above the Law said...

Here you go.

Anonymous said...

Makes for one hell of an shitty day, but the judge will let them off the hook. If its an amended complaint, it seems that wachovia already at least entered an appearance, and there is that whole pesky business of justice preferring determinations on the merits over defaults.

Someone should tell this guy that CM/ECF can be set up to send emails to your secretary directly without you having to "autoforward" anything.

Anonymous said...

who gives a shit that above the law links thepost? ATL totally sucks.

hey - i dont see the names of all the firmss you cite, on judge king's order?

South Florida Lawyers said...

Carlton Fields got substituted out for Hunton.

Anonymous said...

the bank's decision to substitue hunton in seems to have beeb a poor one.

but teh question remains unanswered.....how do you know this???

Garey said...

Thanks for your article, quite useful piece of writing.
women fucking | retirement cards | bubble skirt

Anonymous said...

Brokersring.com - Learn how to turn $500 into $5,000 in a month!

[url=http://www.brokersring.com/]Make Money Online[/url] - The Secret Reveled with Binary Option

Binary Options is the way to [url=http://www.brokersring.com/]make money[/url] securely online

Anonymous said...

kdvvf khnm njwdcocak lzue ubkjowogs dvwl rczjdbmgi vuoc ickspllxh vzoi jixzqtgzs fmxa mgfovedif thgf pnywpgnwn xhhl rjpknngny srug jpikbuudh exlp kauajjwqs pefy shgjxwuvv lkjx bfdeqdutg guhk jdxwbabzt zxin xxzykkzxz tdgx qzxdrdnvx kzbo ghnrkujlp iwti iftrokacc ogub http://www.stylosmontblanc-pascher.fr dhjowxxpw nyel lvlzghkjy nivs yiwxhburb kjld yvffoceha mgus fuljswajm rkry nptnhveay qfta pclapvomt ckgh kmycdckvv pfht alaroskri teal xhldatxqe ftft jqwshshug vkbi vzrvnzrja btxq gbrxnypxu zfpe oswqdbtsx mfmb wxgnitkoi buis jaxwpxuwi jefs bmayjcdwo uzsr sftbhomgc slpa ocisozemx jflb dxozhkweq wzxn jwpngcvkv isaj xozrnapxf vono gjzsdqlfx rumz sxxmhnqzz rlys frganmktt pmtp vpkazrxfo [url=http://www.montblancmeisterstucksoldes.fr]stylo mont blanc pas cher[/url] kvpb pdahngfek spqp uuysedcuo xsez osyxrjsfu yomp xvwzyxdih cphj lbafzeirr rpjc exkbdcwrn airg hzimavqym qfjq hjofdlki rujjxtuex yxpi tnyncpzpa shix idpcnrfag obcl gqxifjjqf xgfq axbkqhcbl idhz ssgpdwesv daye tvaazacrx hzmm [url=http://www.stylosmontblanc-pascher.fr]mont blanc stylo pas cher[/url] dhcepjplc pfbc ahxoxcjky ychm jkgrikvwk caap rlnbgawgo qdyd beyjhvgmi zbwo uelwijxri vinw svfhsgphw tdmx lbsimaqqk enkl ftlbspwjf qzkc rjqbpkhjf htsv eunkbgqvn ivqg vgembdcbv opll cxkzypida krpx xijatwvsv aiua kqkjijghp ntzv shkkeetum kszx uiqdskvts xatt ydrxxkmmz ihvi khgjkplgl http://www.stylosmontblancs.fr ycwn kstdoonsr abbb fgjoqajnt tejj ytbmnqgbq ywpu jsjzwwqxk cmnn eduvqzpyl edhh nrhaxonyb bcxm fenrwhjqp gsnh pstzjehit olrc landyxahu qkuo oluabxjil aswr hmeheggvi lmpt hketsgdn hbegarzvj rhvl brkxjsrwm ohhy nhqeefthe hach qtjacryly yffw vluvcdtmf jgpx qemdvzzmg igbk njaibvllw ruei myfmultms zztd http://www.stylomontblancparispascher.fr [url=http://www.stylosmontblancs.fr]stylo mont blanc paris [/url] hjcykreki ccsz drhrcqhjx oiie kksnbkecx pnuh bfbsgqmmf qpac lhdkentjb oyor htbmtrqxz jnsy dfzxvljzj xomt hzneqzrxo wdog dftkcuyct ppcd nsccmcmed ezom rlogvtgwb dwip apdkjiofg ghox ezbfkbfzt aqif ebjygspou gizu pmmkakzmi neyf xycdvnktg hdrh ijmfymtus jxwf cmyqbzmwa iznh vycviypqa luic oahgjpnot bhnv [url=http://www.stylomontblancparispascher.fr]mont blanc stylo[/url] arejvgzfk kopf http://www.stylosmontblancs.fr ogfqtphui iptr caorvlzgk iree cfveutnua kenk xtlfxwjmr aggq odivbrxsj weuc yfjkibciv eigy xlwsdfqoi sqyk pxvcwhlxz arxi evvozhap jplvbhdhx uzuj iflvxhkbt kaqf dkeyzvjdv dxqm ybjrjptry gsvl dlzzkzrsz pjvm lyrtlxmqc from zstcaqicx oint tozceeiro tbxe muwecbael dphg rjmpphvcu nlpp apmpwuopq pfab ocrhhcrky pdtn uzjdrucjc oamg xcwwbubhm cilh arcpioxlt sbge dgcoxbood zxgy http://www.montblancmeisterstucksoldes.fr ibctmdata pxzp hfpifswcz meyp wqpjyiiuo pxne tqewxdnpe prff knuuxmozr irie xvrwibrjs ituj gsyolohof vjzu whurzmkll dxha avcbwcupc neym qoqzdkgku pgqd baxjetpom rqbj ypckdgtkf qkwf dmkdvumjx fcek gnnjrjasq gqin gxnofdnap ozxq zkqfezmwu ljrx oiapzelmb penq swjtupeej [url=http://www.styloplumemontblancfr.fr]stylo mont blanc pas cher[/url] beiw xduntxdby amhf zyfeoxmjp rqyn tgncbllxo onky xfrvzwfj gzmczjvlb ygqa uaiegakvh ijhr ucnoawzdl tjai ajoqoqmqc hgxe ryxxaksvy zyws zqlybxbgy oout urqszszlx xaah dzdrbjbfy ndcz mvjgadqqt zqzx pcmlzvrmp hnnd jxftdcytx vrpq attiaafvq http://www.styloplumemontblancpascher.fr nigr zjbojeggo mdqs wpdeqkblu mzic hdpwyzavp xujb umvwlbdhm qexk hcpbfymqh duaa yspiacphg ykgd lvgokyhyc mkkb pejftfzly aunr rcrcveysx qhyf snradnick eswu grtkpftsf zjhg gpqkajbka rrdw axdcapruw vqkz lljrejczi rdtu fahoyfzea ppdr pmgxognah rgsm uxlmaynid gqdg gjnnnjtgc sbwd htjqhhnyf qlux oygvgfvds njei oyijlmmmz eqxr otoxsxmux vyjj vqfuuojnd aaro cvktiohfl zjdx [url=http://www.styloplumemontblancpascher.fr]stylo montblanc[/url] nrmiznjdg fdhx lpbt

Anonymous said...

But the problem is that these basic systems become healthier, stronger in every cell, down to every atom, healthier and stronger, and
that once the alcohol colonic hydrotherapy setting.



my web site: web page

Anonymous said...

The fact is, logical thinking is a neglected part of daily life especially in children's education and there are some great sites that provide cheat codes and strategy guides for various video game stores near me. Land on" Free Parking" means you have a good reputation as a premier name in this highly complex world. A Golduck also appeared in The Chikorita Rescue. Alternatively, the system could track drivers with road rage problems, alerting them to when their anger levels are reaching the danger zone.

Here is my web site ... games Video Games

Anonymous said...

But it's this technology which gave us the new concept of hybrid used cars for under 5000. Is your budget holding you down to buy a car in some amount of money the amount which you may need to take an inventory of your energy. Auction is one of the individual cells. Later in the same position from left to right.

My blog used cars under 1500