Tuesday, March 12, 2013

Judge McAliley Grants Lewis Tein's Motion to Compel.




She found that the Tribe did not carry its burden of establishing the "deliberative process privilege":
One central issue was the Plaintiffs assertion of the deliberative process privilege, as an objection to producing portions of minutes, recordings or other documentation of the meetings of the Plaintiff's Business Council and General Council. Both Defendants Lehtinen and Lewis Tein had requested these records in a number of their document requests. Before Plaintiff filed its response to the motions to compel, I reminded Plaintiff of its obligation to fully meet its burden to establish its claims of privilege, and advised that l expected it to do so in its response to the motions to compel.(s'ce DE 151, 1541.

Plaintiff failed to carry this burden. Instead, Plaintiff made conclusory assertions that some of the communications at these Council meetings as protected by this privilege, without identifying the particular communications or providing any evidence to support its claim . In particular, Plaintiff did not provide any declarations from persons with knowledge who might have been able to establish the various elements of the deliberative process privilege - an essential starting point to meeting its burden of proof.l  Accordingly, for the reasons set forth more fully at the discovery conference, I found that Plaintiff failed to carry its burden of proving its claims of privilege and I thus overruled these objections.
She also granted the law firm's demand for production of the Tribe's IRS Forms 1096, with all 1099s that relate to the lawyers or firm.

21 comments:

Anonymous said...

tick...tock

Anonymous said...

Υour currеnt ρost has establisheԁ usеful to myself.
ӏt’s quite helpful and you really arе cleaгly very well-infοrmed οf thіѕ tyрe.

You hаѵe oρenеd up mу еуе to be able to νаrious opіnion of
this matter wіth intriguing, notable and strong artiсles.



Feеl free to viѕit mу blog post - viagra
Feel free to surf my page ; viagra

Anonymous said...

Who from the case is on the little blue pill???

Anonymous said...

Why are you ignoring poor Dexter Lehtinen? Like your beloved Guy Lewis, he was an interim U.S. Attorney, and his motion to compel was granted, too.

Anonymous said...

you don't want some road rage SFL give him love too

Anonymous said...

This case survived MTD?

Anonymous said...

I just checked the docket.

No ruling on MTD.

Anonymous said...

I just checked the docket.

No ruling on MTD.

Anonymous said...

I just checked the docket.

No ruling on MTD.

Anonymous said...

I just checked the docket.

No ruling on MTD.

Anonymous said...

Thanks for checking four times!

Anonymous said...

Anonymous tip: Check 97-CV-2729 [SDFL] recent pleadings regarding Nevin Shapiro and Guy Lewis.

Anonymous said...

Loser

Anonymous said...

Your love and admiration for Lewis and Tein in remarkable. These guys are an embarassment to out profession.

Anonymous said...

You lose

Anonymous said...

This emancipate search mechanism searches the free full-text of over 400 online law reviews and law journals, as marvellously as paper repositories hosting academic papers and related publications such as Congressional Analyse Air force reports. Distinct of the law reviews and legit journals (such as the Stanford Technology Law Review), working papers, and reports are present online only.

http://adeno.lezajsk.pl/biznes-w-malych-firmach/4235/
http://www.lgreengiant.dobrykatalog24.com/index.php?option=com_sobi2&sobi2Task=sobi2Details&sobi2Id=1776&Itemid=1&zmien_css=ruby
http://rayris-ash.com.pl/?p=5793
http://dodani.pl/firmy/postepowanie,sadowe,s,6034/
http://lorban.opoczno.pl/biznes-i-finanse/796/

Anonymous said...

Hey this is κinda of off tоpiс but I was
wanting to know if blogs usе WYSIWYG
editors or if you hаve to manually
code with HTML. I'm starting a blog soon but have no coding expertise so I wanted to get advice from someone with experience. Any help would be enormously appreciated!

My web site :: Chemietoilette

Anonymous said...

A tooth (plural teeth) is a undersized, calcified, whitish build ground in the jaws (or mouths) of various vertebrates and occupied to sever down food. Some animals, surprisingly carnivores, also use teeth repayment for hunting or instead of defensive purposes. The roots of teeth are covered sooner than gums. Teeth are not made of bone, but fairly of multiple tissues of varying density and hardness.

The general design of teeth is alike resemble across the vertebrates, although there is considerable converting in their show up and position. The teeth of mammals have deep roots, and this decoration is also found in some fish, and in crocodilians. In most teleost fish, how, the teeth are fastened to the outer surface of the bone, while in lizards they are fastened to the inner come up of the jaw during the same side. In cartilaginous fish, such as sharks, the teeth are attached around rough ligaments to the hoops of cartilage that accumulate the jaw.

http://mantris.kazimierz-dolny.pl/zdrowie,i,uroda/implanty,zebow,s,833/
http://zakataloguj.pl/zdrowie,i,uroda/ortodonta,katowice,s,5726/
http://www.properia.pl/zdrowie,i,uroda/web,site,s,1965/
http://powerglide.mazowsze.pl/zdrowie,i,uroda/usuniecie,korzenia,zeba,s,952/
http://irelia.com.pl/zdrowie,i,uroda/www,danutaborczyk,pl,s,2160/

http://cribs.pl/zdrowie,i,uroda/wybielanie,zebow,katowice,s,4870/
http://www.galtor.edu.pl/zdrowie,i,uroda/strona,glowna,s,2734/
http://kiksal.pl/zdrowie,i,uroda/chirurgia,stomatologiczna,katowice,s,4900/
http://www.igamron.edu.pl/zdrowie,i,uroda/podniesienie,zatoki,s,1006/
http://warpath.malbork.pl/zdrowie,i,uroda/bezbolesne,leczenie,zebow,s,943/

http://www.getlinklist.edu.pl/zdrowie,i,uroda/podniesienie,zatoki,s,644/
http://sathra.pl/firmy/zatoki,szczekowe,leczenie,s,1848/
http://www.orpus.edu.pl/zdrowie,i,uroda/aparat,ortodontyczny,katowice,s,3431/
http://wykatalogowany.pl/firmy/zatoki,szczekowe,s,2869/
http://frack.pl/zdrowie,i,uroda/medycyna,estetyczna,katowice,s,4824/

Anonymous said...

Tyya's dad won't acquire mad anything fit at the set aside - no ice cream, no sweetmeats, no cookies. But when the saleslady puts a assay sticker on Tyya's nose, Daddy is conclusively feigned to gather something good

http://www.webhunter.pl/?p=1


http://piepszyc.pl/tag/uwaga
http://mk.org.pl/tag/naturalne-barwy
http://krolik-bugs.com/481,zdjecie.html
http://pracagdynia.net.pl/?id=68011&o=inspektor_realizujacy_funkcje_publicznoprawne
http://aromatyczna-kuchnia.eu/nori.php

Anonymous said...

Global Industrial coupon codes are codes that you can partake of to get discounts upon your shopping at pandemic industrial online or not. Coupon codes released alongside the proprietorship adequate as attend of the companions their steadfast customers.
http://www.kataloguj.info/tag,prezydent/
http://www.dorlom.edu.pl/firmy/nagrzewnice,wodne,s,2208/
http://www.kataloguj.info/tag,torebki,sklep,internetowy/
http://blog.despiezalo.com/2011/07/despiece-de-una-camara-ip/sanyo-digital-camera-11/?replytocom=4797
http://www.kataloguj.info/tag,portale/

http://stroec.edu.pl/biznes/3975/
http://kakal.com.pl/interesy-biznesowe/4849/
http://elektrykadzierzoniow.pl/nagrzewnice/
http://www.kataloguj.info/tag,bittorrent/
http://www.kataloguj.info/?action=premium&id=82

Anonymous said...

Two outstanding manufacturers of special healing products are pulling sundry well-received brands from the market because they may contain traces of poultry antibiotics that are not approved in the U.S.

http://www.biznesdlafirm.com/katalog/porednictwo-ubezpieczeniowe-tomex-tomasz-machnicki
http://centrum-firm.com/katalog/pokaz/2329
http://www.promowanefirmy.pl/katalog/pokaz/5875
http://www.promowanefirmy.pl/katalog/szukaj/cat/29/strona/15
http://www.centrum-firm.com/katalog/pokaz/5389

http://centrum-firm.com/katalog/pokaz/1418
http://www.centrum-firm.com/katalog/pokaz/1658
http://promowanefirmy.pl/katalog/pokaz/4926
http://centrum-firm.com/katalog/pokaz/3397
http://promowanefirmy.pl/katalog/pokaz/4309