Immune System of Bankruptcy Lawyer Further Imperiled by 11th Circuit Affirmance.

It's not easy being "extremely Floridian."

I like the lawyers at GrayRobinson, and I think they have a smart business model.

So I'm ready to write something positive, if one of you shmarties over on Brickell would send me some good news.

Instead, I have to report on this 11th Circuit opinion issued yesterday, which affirms a Middle District affirmance of a bankruptcy court sanctions order against attorney Peter Ginsberg of Peter R. Ginsberg P.C. (now at Crowell & Moring), and GrayRobinson lawyers Scott Spradley (who doesn't appear to work there anymore) and Maureen Vitucci, who served as local counsel for Ginsberg and also represented several other parties to the bankruptcy.

First off, it's just wrong that any order has to go on for eight pages before the opinion actually starts.

But once it gets going it's an interesting read. Apparently the sanctions order grew out of motion to recuse that the court determined was principally drafted by Ginsberg. In the sanctions order, the bankruptcy judge imposed monetary sanctions of $371k and barred Ginsberg from practicing in the Middle District bankruptcy court for five years.

GrayRobinson then settled their portion of the sanctions for $300k, which the bankruptcy judge approved.

I would read the whole thing, but I was particularly struck by the 11th Circuit's discussion of the tone of Ginsberg's filing and courtroom demeanor, which starts on page 44.

Here's Judge Fay on how Ginsberg treated the bankruptcy judge he had sought to recuse:
Further, Ginsberg was extremely difficult to deal with and disrespectful to
the court. He refused to answer the court's questions, treated the court as an adversary and continually made inflammatory statements. For example, Ginsberg
exaggerated the implications of Judge Briskman’s actions, alleging that his
conduct “relates directly to the judicial processes, namely the integrity of trial
transcripts, and a party’s due process rights and liberty.” (Recusal Mot. at 19.)

Ginsberg opened the Recusal Hearing by claiming: "Your honor has compromised my health, your Honor has compromised my immune system." (Recusal Tr. Vol. I
at 5.) Ginsberg also used accusatory, unsupported language in the three petitions
for writ of mandamus; asserted that Judge Briskman faced “potential career ending
punishment”; and accused him of trying to surreptitiously “brush the matter under
the carpet” so he could “retain authority over these very important issues of
judicial and professional conduct." (Response Br. at 16.)

Ginsberg also purposefully pursued recusal very publicly. After learning of
Hudson's Complaint, Ginsberg did not first request a private hearing with Judge
Briskman and all counsel in these cases to address his concerns, nor did he file the
Recusal Motion under seal (ignoring the preference for confidentiality inherent in
the Judicial Council Rules discussed below). Instead, the first time Ginsberg
raised the Complaint was in a 31-page accusatory motion which used the term
"investigation" twelve times and referenced adverse rulings fifty-four times.
Ginsberg also immediately brought the Recusal Motion to the attention of the
district court. He filed three petitions for a writ of mandamus with the district
court while the Recusal Motion was still pending.

In our view, Ginsberg’s dogged pursuit of a frivolous claim indicates bad
"Your Honor compromised my immune system"??

Seriously? That's really your opening, Peter?

Take some Naturebee and buck up, soldier.
Reblog this post [with Zemanta]


  1. really...compromised his immune system!?! What a crock.

  2. compromised-my-immune-system-for-the-princessJune 12, 2009 at 12:28 PM

    Talk about bad judgment all around.

  3. GrayRobinson is a big joke. Inferior lawyering. Lots of ethical transgressions.

  4. naturebee-lovers-of-the-latinaJune 12, 2009 at 2:32 PM

    That may be one of the funniest opening arguments I ever heard.

  5. naturebee-lovers-of-the-latina-1June 12, 2009 at 4:32 PM

    Ditto 2:32

  6. During the relevant proceedings Ginsberg had stage 4 throat cancer and was undergoing radiation and chemotherapy following aggressive surgery. That's what Ginsberg was referring to regarding "immune system". Judge would not grant a continuance.

  7. William D. Schroeder, JrJuly 27, 2009 at 8:12 AM

    Yes i was struck by the 11th Circuit's discussion too and courtroom demeanor of bankruptcy lawyer Ginsberg. How can he open the Recusal Hearing by claiming: "Your honor has compromised my health, your Honor has compromised my immune system", is completly out of context.

  8. I recently came across your blog and have been reading about Commercial Liability Insurance. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.

  9. wow, get your facts straight before slandering someone. it makes perfect sense for that to be his opening given that he was undergoing treatment for cancer and the judge wouldn't grant a continuance. do a little research before your next big post, will you?

  10. This is awesome, it countered some contradictions I had heard.

  11. There are variety of herbal remedies on market that can be helpful for boosting immune system of body. When choosing these remedies, it is helpful to look for whole foods & fresh herbs, as these tend to provide the most powerful potency. Our bodies are better able to absorb nutritional value from these more wholesome foods, so your immune system will get a more beneficial boost.

  12. Going through the process of filing, however, prove overwhelming, especially if you may have little knowledge of bankruptcy laws in your state. Obtain the services of a reputable lawyer to help you in this matter.

    Bankruptcy Suffolk County, NY

  13. If you are tired of ducking bill collectors, throwing your mail in the garbage unread and hoping your problems will just go away it may be time to talk to a bankruptcy lawyer.

  14. I truly like to reading your post. Thank you so much for taking the time to share such a nice information.

  15. Now it seems someone really decided to put on their thinking cap, great going! It’s fantastic to see people really writing about the important thing. Thanks for sharing.

  16. Nice blog better to keep it up! On the other hand I'm looking for the post of bankruptcy lawyer in San Antonio.

  17. Nice blog, thanks for sharing the information. I will come to look for update. Keep up the good work.

    bankruptcy lawyer gloucester ma

  18. Cartoon women move it each individual which strategies by these types of comic strip instances of down and dirty nipple play scenarios. [url=]Quite cute dark chick fierce screwing A couple of[/url] Experienced elderly woman takes your ex boss's john thomas earlier than sitting to come back and getting fucked in the vagina , Lanny Barbie items Screws Within a Remove Golf club People exhibiting their tight rear end with skinny jeans do away with next to the other person and even the perfect contour Nikki Rogue contacting men prostitute , Captivating amateur slut on bra and also thong can get bare for those video camera and even distributes the girl's pussy cheekbones large.

  19. “Congratulations South Florida Lawyers ! Thank you so much for taking the time to share this exciting information.”

    read more


Post a Comment